Matty's Carpet and Air Duct Cleaning

Matty’s Carpet & Air Duct Cleaning

Clean or Replace Carpet (What to do!)

Have you ever found yourself staring at a stained, frayed carpet, wondering whether it’s time to hire a professional cleaning service or simply throw in the towel and buy a new one? You’re not alone. It’s a common conundrum many homeowners face. But fear not, this guide is here to help you weigh the factors that affect this pivotal decision. Buckle up, let’s dive in.

Carpet Cleaning Companies Thornton CO

Cost Analysis

Initial costs: Comparison of the cost of buying new carpets vs. professional cleaning of old carpets

Purchasing a brand new carpet might seem like an attractive option. It promises a fresh start, a new look. But the cost? Well, that can be a sticking point. New carpets, especially high-quality ones, can be quite expensive, typically ranging from $7 to $12 per square foot, including installation. This can add up quickly in larger rooms.

On the other hand, professional carpet cleaning services, like those we offer at Matty’s Carpet Cleaning, are significantly more cost-effective in the short term. The average price for professional carpet cleaning ranges from $25 to $75 per room, depending on the size and state of the carpet.

Long-term costs: Maintenance, cleaning, and replacement costs of new and old carpets

However, the initial costs don’t paint the full picture. Long-term costs, including maintenance and cleaning, are equally important. New carpets require professional cleaning every 12 to 18 months to maintain their warranty and prolong their lifespan. Regular maintenance of older carpets can extend their life, delay replacement costs, and keep them looking sprightly for longer.

Carpet Lifespan

Understanding the typical lifespan of a carpet

The lifespan of a carpet is typically around 10 to 15 years. However, it can vary greatly depending on the carpet material, quality, usage, and maintenance. Wool carpets may last for decades with proper care, while certain synthetic carpets might show wear after only 5 years.

Indicators of an end-of-life carpet

Signs that your carpet is at the end of its life include visible wear in high traffic areas, stubborn stains that won’t budge, persistent odors, and deteriorating carpet padding. If these signs are widespread, replacement might be the best bet.

How regular cleaning impacts carpet lifespan

Regular cleaning can significantly increase a carpet’s lifespan by preventing dirt and grime from grinding into the carpet fibers. Deep cleaning, like what we do at Matty’s Carpet Cleaning, can rejuvenate an old carpet and make it feel almost as good as new. It’s the metaphorical fountain of youth for carpets!

Allergens and Health Considerations

Carpet’s role in harboring allergens and potential health effects

Your beloved carpet could be a hotspot for allergens such as dust mites, pet dander, and mold spores. These can potentially exacerbate allergies or asthma in sensitive individuals.

Effectiveness of professional cleaning in removing allergens

Professional carpet cleaning uses powerful equipment and specific cleaning solutions to eliminate these allergens. A clean carpet contributes to a healthier indoor environment.

Considerations for new carpets and allergen accumulation

While a new carpet initially has fewer allergens, without regular cleaning, it can soon become a haven for them just like an old carpet.

Aesthetic and Comfort

The role of carpets in a room's overall aesthetic

Carpets play a significant role in a room’s overall aesthetic. They add warmth and color, and can make a room look more inviting and comfortable.

Impact of cleaning and wear on carpet aesthetics

Over time, carpets can lose their vibrancy due to dirt, stains, and wear. Regular cleaning can help maintain their appearance, but it may not fully restore a heavily worn carpet.

Comparisons of the aesthetic and comfort options for new carpets

A new carpet offers a chance to update your room’s aesthetic. You can choose from a variety of colors, patterns, and pile heights to match your room’s style and your personal comfort preferences.

Environmental Impact

Environmental considerations when disposing of old carpets

When deciding whether to replace or clean, one should also consider the environmental implications. Old carpets often end up in landfills and can take many years to degrade.

carpet getting replaced

The environmental footprint of carpet manufacturing

The production of new carpets involves energy-intensive processes and can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. Not to mention, synthetic carpets are petroleum-based products.

Evaluation of the environmental implications of professional carpet cleaning

Professional carpet cleaning, on the other hand, is generally more eco-friendly. It uses less water and energy than carpet production, and many companies use green cleaning solutions.

Decision Factors

How to weigh the above factors based on personal priorities and circumstances

When deciding whether to clean or replace your carpet, weigh these factors against your budget, your aesthetic preferences, your environmental concerns, and your health considerations.

Remember, if your carpet is showing signs of severe wear or has become a health hazard, replacement may be the best option. But in many cases, a professional cleaning can breathe new life into your carpets and postpone the need for replacement.

Frequently Asked Questions

This depends on several factors such as the age and condition of your carpet, your budget, and your personal preferences. If your carpet is severely worn out or damaged, replacement may be necessary. Otherwise, professional cleaning can often refresh a tired carpet.

Yes, professional cleaning can remove deeply ingrained dirt and allergens that regular vacuuming can’t reach. It can extend your carpet’s lifespan, maintain its appearance, and improve the indoor air quality of your home.

Look for signs like widespread stains, persistent odors, visible wear in high traffic areas, and deteriorating carpet padding. If your carpet is more than 10 years old, these signs are likely indicating that it’s time for a replacement.

Yes, professional carpet cleaning can significantly reduce the level of allergens in your carpet, leading to a healthier indoor environment.


Deciding whether to clean or replace your carpet is a significant decision. Considering factors like cost, lifespan, health implications, aesthetics, and environmental impact can help you make an informed choice. More often than not, regular professional cleaning can extend your carpet’s lifespan, maintain its appearance, and create a healthier living environment, saving you money and reducing environmental impact.

Spring Cleaning Special